PISCATAWAY, NJ - FEBRUARY 23: Tylil James streamer/content creator prior to the game between the Rutgers Scarlet Knights and the USC Trojans on February 23, 2025 at Jersey Mikes Arena in Piscataway, New Jersey. (Photo by Rich Graessle/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)
Fans are trying to figure out whats really going on between streamer Tylil James and his estranged girlfriend, Kae Critch. The internet is buzzing after Tylil shared a new photo with Kae, leaving social media users wondering whether the couple has rekindled their relationship following their public drama late last year.
On Sunday, March 15, Tylil James shared a selfie on social media featuring Kae Critch, sparking speculation that the two may be back together. In the photo, Tylil holds his phone for a mirror selfie while Kae stands behind him with her arms wrapped around his body. She rests her head on him as the couple shows off their matching eye patches. The cozy snapshot quickly caught fans attention, especially since many believed the pair had split months earlier.
The Shade Room Teens comment section quickly filled with reactions after Tylil posted the photo. While some users defended Kae for giving the relationship another chance, others questioned whether getting back together after the couples past issues was the right move.
Instagram user @itsyagirlyanaaa wrote, I thought-
Another Instagram user @lifewitheshiaaa wrote, At least hope she cheat back if she not gone leave
While Instagram user @krissyxraee wrote, lets not act like yall didnt double back on a n**** before
Instagram user @ms.yasminsimone wrote, Chileee anyways
Another Instagram user @luvlycee wrote, yall normalize being a a little tewww much
While Instagram user @shyywayy_ wrote, she shouldve told him not to post her if she was gone get back with him wed be a private relationship
Instagram user @robinantoinette_ wrote, You Aint Wrong Queen
Another Instagram user @nogramzari wrote, How you let him cheat and take him back must be your only n*** -Latto
While Instagram user @niirosee wrote, This is why I stay out of ppl business
Tylils latest post surprised many fans who believed the relationship had ended after a cheating controversy involving the streamer. In December 2025, singer Jourdin Pauline went online with allegations that she had been sexually assaulted by Tylil James following the 2025 Streamer Awards. Tylil denied the allegations at the time, saying the interaction between the two was consensual. However, he admitted the situation became tense after he received a call from Kae Kritch while he and Pauline were together.Amid the backlash, Tylil later took to Instagram Stories to apologize to Kae and publicly expressed his love for her. Shortly after, Kae appeared to distance herself from the situation, posting on her own Instagram Story, I am NOT in a relationship.
Now, months later, Tylils latest post has social media users questioning whether the couple has quietly reconciled.
