Nathan Potier and Erica Palmer were arrested this week in Nevada after authorities say they allegedly forced a 14-year-old girl to become pregnant with Potier’s twins because Palmer could not conceive. The shocking case has raised serious questions about abuse, exploitation, and how far some will go in pursuit of their own desires.
RELATED: Wait, WHAT?! 21 Kids Taken From California Couple After Sketchy Hospital Visit & Claims They Misled Surrogate Mothers
Oklahoma Couple Arrested In Nevada Child Abuse Case
According to officials, the pair was located in the Reno-Sparks area by the United States Marshals Nevada Violent Offender Task Force after being fugitives. Potier faces one count of sexual assault of a child, while Palmer faces one count of enabling sexual abuse of a child. The arrests followed an investigation by the Regional Sex Offender Notification Unit, a multi-jurisdictional partnership that tracks and prosecutes offenders, highlighting the collaborative effort that led to bringing the couple into custody.
Oklahoma Couple Targeted Teen, Fled During Investigation
Investigators say the case first came to light in December 2025 when a caseworker with Oklahoma Child Protective Services flagged that a 14-year-old girl was pregnant with twins. Authorities allege the couple targeted the teen, with Nathan Potier fathering the children. Reportedly, Erica Palmer told police she wanted children with Potier but could not conceive due to a prior tubal ligation, and court documents suggest they fled Oklahoma to avoid authorities while investigators were gathering evidence, including DNA tests.
Teen Victim In Foster Care, Couple Faces Charges
Court filings also indicate a troubling history: earlier reports from California alleged Potier abused the same teen, and Palmer was allegedly aware of those incidents. The teenage victim is now in foster care, while Potier and Palmer remain in the Washoe County Detention Facility on bonds of $300,000 and $200,000, respectively, awaiting extradition back to Oklahoma to face charges.
