Former daycare workers Cathy Stevick, Kendasja Hughley and Shelby Webb were indicted on multiple child-abuse charges in Forsyth, Georgia. The three women were indicted on Monday, November 9, after reports claimed at least one daycare worker was drugging toddlers with Benadryl.
RELATED: Oh Nah! 11-Month-Old Baby Survives Being Buried Alive For 24 Hours By His Father In South Carolina
Three Former Daycare Workers Indicted On Child Abuse Charges
Three former daycare workers at the Forsyth Methodist Church daycare were indicted on multiple counts of child abuse, according to WMGT. Cathy Stevick, Kendasja Hughley and Shelby Webb were arrested in 2025 after an investigation allegedly found several child abuse incidents. The investigation began after one worker was reportedly seen drugging toddlers with Benadryl to make them sleep.
The three women were indicted on 23 criminal counts that include first-degree cruelty to children. In addition, the charges include seven counts of simple battery and five counts of reckless conduct. Webb is charged with one count of first-degree cruelty to children and one count of simple battery for hitting a child. She is also accused of throwing a child out of a chair.
Stay Connected
Subscribe to updates from The Shade Room
Meanwhile, Hughley is accused of kicking a cot with a child in it. She’s also accused of hitting, grabbing, and pulling the children by the hair. She was charged with six first-degree counts of cruelty to children. Furthermore, she was charged with five counts of reckless conduct for allegedly giving toddlers Benadryl, and seven counts of simple battery, per 13 WMAZ.
Hughley was arrested on March 10, 2025. Meanwhile, Webb and Stevick were arrested on March 18, 2025.
Daycare Worker Allegedly Drugs Toddlers With Benadryl
Monroe County Sheriff’s Office contends that on March 5, 2025, Hughley gave a two-and-a-half-year-old toddler under her care Benadryl to make them sleepy at nap time, per WGXA. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office was alerted on March 9, 2025, and subsequently issued an arrest warrant. Ultimately, Hughley turned herself in at the Monroe County Jail. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office was reportedly alerted after another daycare worker witnessed Hughley drugging the toddlers. Another staffer was reportedly seen administering Benadryl to a toddler on March 3, 2025. But it’s unclear if it was Hughley. The witness reportedly told the Forsyth Methodist Church Caring for Kids director, Cathy Stevick.
Forsyth Methodist Church Daycare Director Also Indicted
Cathy Stevick is the former director of Forsyth Methodist Church daycare. Stevick was charged with three counts of failure to report child abuse. According to prosecutors, Stevick was required to report the incidents by law, which allegedly involved three children. Subsequently, the Forsyth Methodist Church daycare license was revoked by the Department of Early Care and Learning.
In addition, earlier this year, six families filed a lawsuit against the church daycare, per 13 WMAZ. One family, Clint and Jessica Smith, said they knew something was wrong when they picked their daughter up from school, but they never knew why.
“She was tired when we picked her up, not her normal happy self,” said Mr. Smith. “She was quieter, less playful, and seemed off. That was hard to see.”
Mrs. Smith added that she later learned her child was drugged with Benadryl on social media. Attorneys Bill Arnold and Kevin Patrick are representing the families.
“I was contacted early on by one of the family members,” said Arnold. “When we met in person with all six families, I realized they were here for all the right reasons to hold someone accountable and protect future children. They want answers, accountability, and to make sure this doesn’t happen again.”


